Can juice prevent weight gain? Preemies break ALL the rules.

IMG_0244
I have long been opposed to fruit juice. As a life-long dieter I know just 6 oz of the stuff packs a whopping 100 calories and not much else. I’d rather have some chocolate. As a doctor I know fruit juice is associated with childhood obesity and kids allowed to to take a bottle of juice to bed risk cavities.

So when we started introducing foods to Oliver at 9 months I never considered juice (I wasn’t neglecting Victor, he was just not having any of that food nonsense, thank you oral aversion!).

The first juice exposure came at the age of 18 months. Hospitalized with croup, on oxygen, and unable to eat , Oliver was getting dehydrated. To spare him an IV the nurse suggested we try juice. “Sure, why not?” I replied.

Dear God, could that boy drink juice. Gallons. Oliver’s love of juice got him through 4 major hospitalizations for pneumonia without an IV. That’s right. Fever of 104, on oxygen, delirious but that boy could pull it together long enough to slug back 4 ounces before passing out again. At home, since he was having trouble gaining weight, I figured what the heck. The medical literature clearly indicates that juice is associated with excessive weight gain, so I said BRING IT ON!

But he is almost 7 years old and he wears size 4. He is the 3rd percentile for weight and 7th for height. His bum heart and bum lungs require a lot of calories, about 1,800 a day. The problem is he only gets about 1,200.

I watched him eat like a hawk for a week. Pediasure for breakfast, lunch at school so who the hell knows (although juice box always emptied when nothing else is touched), and a glass and a half of juice often drained at the dinner table before his first bite of food. And then after 3 bites, all done.

Hmmm. Could the empty juice calories be the cause?

We discussed it, lots of crying. No more juice before a meal. Ever. More crying.

“Milk is OK,” I said. Whole milk has more calories and also provides one big thing juice is missing: protein. Preemie lungs chew up protein like crazy while they repair themselves.

After few tearful meals Oliver has accepted the juice ban. Sometimes asks for water and sometimes milk and I am OK with either. He is eating more. Not a lot, but more. He still asks – that boy is nothing if not persistent. I tell him he can have it for dessert, but usually he chooses ice cream (another great way to sneak in calories and some extra protein).

I am still OK with juice in the hospital. It’s better than an IV, but that’s about all it’s good for.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Can juice prevent weight gain? Preemies break ALL the rules.

  1. cindy bailey says:

    Really nice blog!

  2. Melissa says:

    Our 22 month old preemie (born at 26 weeks) has still never had juice. Like you, I don’t see the benefits for her! (She’s gonna be mad at me when she figures out what I’ve been holding back–but she gets Pediasure and that’s plenty sweet!)

  3. beth says:

    I’m the mom of a 27weeker who is now 4 and has NEVER had much of an appetite, but no significant oral aversions. I’m also a peds PT.
    I thought I should give my daughter the most calorie-packed liquids I could. I, like you, was not concerned with obesity – quite the opposite for my tiny one.

    Here’s the advice I got re:juice and whole milk. No major data to back it up but it seems to have heled lately.

    My sister is a “behavior interventionist” who specializes in feeding disorders. Her suggestion was that the juice raises these kids blood sugar so quickly, it tells their brain they are full, and then they won’t eat the healthy solid food that we lovingly prepared. No more juice unless its a treat or we’re at a restaraunt.

    My friend is an RD and recommended I cut off the whole milk just recently. I plead my case and said i was trying to get more colories in her. She said the milk is good, especially for protein, like you said. However, low-fat milk has more protein per ounce because the fat was removed. The whole mil also may be making her feel more full, so she’s not getting the other nutrients on the plate. So we switched to 2% and her appetite HAS incresed!! Not a huge amount, mind you, but enough for me to be a believer.

    anyhow – that’s my 2c. I had the same thoughts as you so I thought I’d share.

    Good luck with your boys, they are beautiful. . .

  4. chetana says:

    Hello everyone,
    I am new to this site but so glad that I found this. I have a 33 week premie boy who is now one year eight months. He is majorly addicted to bottle milk and has started refusing to eat any other solid food. I tried not giving him bottle but he created such big rucus i couldnt help giving in. Now, I am worried as he is refusing to eat anything. Any suggestions? He weighs 9.3kgs

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>